Rethinking Modernism In Music History

Short Essay #2 Rethinking Modernism
At a time when musicologys sights seem set ever more squarely on eradicating boundariesthe study of modernism can seem a rather antiquated concern. Modernism is arguably all about boundaries, in the heightened sense that it is itself a contested category, whose only red thread seems to have been an investment in distinction and hierarchy.

Rethinking Modernism In Music History
Just from $10/Page
Order Essay
from Christopher Chowrimootoo, Reviving the Middlebrow, or: Deconstructing Modernism from the Inside, inJournal of the Royal Musical Association, vol. 139, no. 1 (2014), p. 188.
What does it mean for music to be modern? And why should we care? For the last few decades, musicologists have thought about these questions, finding that modernist composers often defined themselves by differentiating their work both from traditional forms of expression and from mass popular culture. Although this so-called great divide between art and popular music, between traditional and progressive ideas is prevalent in many primary sources, it need not be the only way we think about the last 150 years of music history.
Please read Christopher Chowrimootoos Reviving the Middlebrow (pp. 187-193 in the Modernism and its Others PDF. Chowrimootoo claims that we should begin to rethink this history of modern music by paying more attention to middlebrow music: repertories that fall somewhere in between modernisms divides. Write a brief essay in which you try this approach: consider music that does not align neatly with clear categorizations and hierarchies, and reflect on how understanding this music might impact our understanding of music history.
Your essay should address the following points:
How do you understand the great divide discussed on p. 188? How has it affected our discussions of music history, and of music more generally? Please expand on Chowrimootoos short discussion by briefly citing examples of composers or pieces from different sides of the divide (at least one from each side).
What does Chowrimootoo mean by middlebrow (introduced on p. 190)? What, specifically, does paying more attention to middlebrow music do to help our understanding of music history more generally?
Select a piece (from the syllabus or elsewhere), and consider it from the middlebrow perspective. How does it fit between tradition and innovation? Between high art and popular culture? Be specific, and be sure to consider both its musical features and its historical context.
Do you think music history ought to focus more on these middlebrow pieces? How should they be balanced with our understanding of a more divided view of modernism?